.
Feedback

Candidates Are Anti-Subway Route Under School

Candidates for the 50th Assembly District, which covers Beverly Hills, Santa Monica, Brentwood and Pacific Palisades, are voicing opposition to tunneling underneath Beverly Hills High School.

The four candidates running for the said in an interview airing April 2 that they oppose a subway stop at Constellation Avenue, a route that would go under .

The Westside Subway Extension is an expansion of the Purple Line to Century City, Westwood and the Veterans Administration campus. Beverly Hills, Santa Monica and Brentwood are in the 50th Assembly District, but Century City and Westwood are not.

Democrats Betsy Butler, Torie Osborn, Richard Bloom and Republican Brad Torgan all appeared on the program Inside Beverly Hills, a public affairs show produced by the Beverly Hills city government. The program is hosted by local journalist Rudy Cole, who told Patch that he asked the candidates their views on Metro’s plans to tunnel under BHHS as part of the Westside Subway Extension.

"All four candidates agreed that the subway route should not go under the high school," Cole said.

The MTA released its Environmental Impact Report in which it endorsed a subway stop at Constellation Boulevard and Avenue of the Stars instead of a stop on Santa Monica Boulevard. Putting a stop at Constellation Boulevard would require tunneling under Beverly Hills High School.

Metro is hosting an open house on the Westside Subway Extension in Westwood on Wednesday night. For more information, .

The Beverly Hills Unified School District has asked families to attend the meeting to voice their opposition to the subway route.

"Despite our protests Metro has decided that the Century City subway station should be at Constellation Boulevard—which means Metro will tunnel under Beverly Hills High School if the Metro Board approves this report," the email said. "We need your support and voice to stop this injustice."

All five Beverly Hills district PTAs made similar points in their school newsletters this week. The PTA Council, an umbrella group that represents the Beverly Hills PTAs, voted Tuesday to spend up to $3,500 on banners and signs at school sites opposing the subway route.

Beverly Hills  told the PTA Council that the City Council is "united and uniform" in its opposition to a subway route under BHHS.

The Beverly Hills City Council will hold a closed session April 3 to discuss possible new actions to take to oppose the subway route, Brien said. The mayor encouraged parents to attend the Thursday MTA meeting in Beverly Hills, although he will be unable to be there because of a prior commitment in Washington, D.C.  

Board of Education President Brian Goldberg is one of several board members who have visited PTA meetings to urge parents to attend the Thursday meeting. At a recent Horace Mann PTA meeting, he suggested parents contact County Supervisor , whose district includes Beverly Hills. Yaroslavsky is on the MTA board that must give the final approval on the Westside Subway extension.

"Email is not so effective anymore," Goldberg said. "Please pick up the phone and call Zev’s office."

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Westwood-Century City Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Kate Svoboda-Spanbock March 29, 2012 at 11:29 am
Injustice? Seriously?
Babettte March 29, 2012 at 12:12 pm
What are the reasons not going under the school, will it effect the school or students?
Minoter March 29, 2012 at 12:48 pm
What do you expect these candidates to say when they're appearing before a Beverly Hills City organization. They knew what that niche of voters had to hear. Why bother with the facts, go for the votes, eh?
centurycitysubway.org March 29, 2012 at 02:24 pm
@ Babette There are numerous concerns about locating the subway tunnel beneath Beverly Hills High School, or any public school building; something that has never been done in the State of California. A recent independent study commissioned by the City of Beverly Hills raised several significant safety concerns about the proposed construction, which would require major tunneling under a school that is more than 80 years old. What's more, the construction could seriously impact construction and modernization plans that are a part of a bond measure that was passed by Beverly Hills voters several years ago. Finally, according to the Draft EIR and experts retained by the BHUSD and the City of Beverly Hills, the proposed station at Santa Monica Blvd. and Ave. of the Stars would be at least $60 millon cheaper, have more riders and be faster than the Constellation option. Please visit www.centurycitysubway.org for more information and details about this important issue.
Minoter March 29, 2012 at 03:16 pm
There is a subway under a new school at Wilshire and Vermont. there is a subway under the Pentagon, for heaven sakes! A new museum with subterranean parking in LA will have the subway running under it. The the proposed route will tunnel under Westwood homes built in the 20's and 30's. Buying into the high priced PR firms website will get you no facts, only spins.
centurycitysubway.org March 29, 2012 at 03:32 pm
@ Big Shorty The subway tunnel at Wilshire and Vermont runs under an empty field, not a school building. That is obviously a major difference. And a museum is not a good analogy because museums don't have to comply with the Field Act (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Field_Act) or be approved by the CA Department of State Architect. Likewise with the Pentagon, which is in Virginia and doesn't have the same issues as we face in California. We encourage everyone to look at all of the facts related to this important issue. Please visit www.centurycitysubway.org for more information.
Dylan Rush March 29, 2012 at 03:49 pm
This is a pretty obvious objection ... it's okay to run a subway under a school filled with children, as long as they are not the children of the rich. And so we move ever closer to being the third-world country that we aspire to.
Chris Loos March 29, 2012 at 04:17 pm
There are metro tunnels in DC that go beneath buildings that are 150 years old. There are tunnels in London that go beneath buildings that are 400 years old. What's your point? We're talking about tunnels 75 feet underground, dug with state of the art tunnel boring machines. Its not like we're talking about digging just beneath the foundations or something.
Chris Loos March 29, 2012 at 04:18 pm
For those that don't know, centurycitysubway.org is a website run by a PR firm Bevery Hills Unified School District hired to spin the issue in their favor. They were paid several hundred thousand dollars for their efforts.
Gary Kavanagh March 29, 2012 at 09:48 pm
It is disappointing that there is not a single candidate I can support now, as all of them have thrown out good sense, and concern for the region as a whole, in order to chase the whims of the wealthy and whiney interests of Beverly Hills.
There are subways running under buildings in Europe that have been around since about the time of America declaring independence. The absurd list of excuses used to justify this position knows no bounds. The Beverly Hills Courier even had the audacity to run the headline "Metro On Track To Destroy Beverly Hills High". What an embarrassment.
Chris Loos March 29, 2012 at 10:02 pm
Curbed and Streetsblog DID call that story the "Alarmist headline of the decade" and an "Early 2012 Streetsie Award for Worst Headline" respectively, so kudos to the Courier for that distinction.
Richard F. March 30, 2012 at 12:19 pm
Exactly.
Richard F. March 30, 2012 at 12:23 pm
What a load of crap! This is earthquake country; if that poor, 80-year old building can't survive being tunnelled under it needs to be torn down and replaced. Hey, they could build a subway tunnel under it while they are at it!
Richard F. March 30, 2012 at 12:23 pm
Busted! Good catch, Chris!
Erik Griswold April 3, 2012 at 01:23 pm
There is a Subway under San Diego State University. There are subways (Muni and BART) under multiple schools in the Bay Area. Enough with this canard!
Erik Griswold April 3, 2012 at 01:34 pm
Portland, Oregon is also in an Earthquake zone. Their system has a tunnel which runs from Goose Hollow to the the Sunset Transit Center linking downtown Portland with the western suburbs. It runs right below East Sylvan Middle School.
http://g.co/maps/tccb6
Erik Griswold April 3, 2012 at 01:39 pm
Be careful what you wish for because preliminary study of the Seattle Link system and the Vancouver, B.C. SkyTrain system shows that they have portions which run in tunnel under a variety of public and private educational facilities as well.
George Vreeland Hill April 5, 2012 at 01:17 am
Metro needs to forget about Beverly Hills High School.
I do believe a tunnel under BHHS would not be dangerous as Metro has said. However, I also believe a tunnel under the school would mean the land would not be as safe as it was before. Also, the school may need to build, rebuild or expand in the future to meet the needs of the school, its students and the city. A tunnel would make those future endeavors much harder if not impossible. Because our children come first, the tunnel needs to be built elsewhere. George Vreeland Hill
Richard F. April 5, 2012 at 01:25 pm
"However, I also believe a tunnel under the school would mean the land would not be as safe as it was before."
No offense, George, but this is an engineering issue, not a matter of faith.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something